Wednesday, May 3, 2017

Francisco Goya, "3 de Mayo" (1808)

from Wikipedia:
The Third of May 1808 is set in the early hours of the morning following the uprising and centers on two masses of men: one a rigidly poised firing squad, the other a disorganized group of captives held at gun point. Executioners and victims face each other abruptly across a narrow space; according to Kenneth Clark, "by a stroke of genius [Goya] has contrasted the fierce repetition of the soldiers' attitudes and the steely line of their rifles, with the crumbling irregularity of their target." A square lantern situated on the ground between the two groups throws a dramatic light on the scene. The brightest illumination falls on the huddled victims to the left, whose numbers include a monk or friar in prayer. To the immediate right and at the center of the canvas, other condemned figures stand next in line to be shot. The central figure is the brilliantly lit man kneeling amid the bloodied corpses of those already executed, his arms flung wide in either appeal or defiance.[24] His yellow and white clothing repeats the colors of the lantern. His plain white shirt and sun-burnt face show he is a simple laborer.

On the right side stands the firing squad, engulfed in shadow and painted as a monolithic unit. Seen nearly from behind, their bayonets and their shako headgear form a relentless and immutable column. Most of the faces of the figures cannot be seen, but the face of the man to the right of the main victim, peeping fearfully towards the soldiers, acts as a repoussoir at the back of the central group. Without distracting from the intensity of the foreground drama, a townscape with a steeple looms in the nocturnal distance, probably including the barracks used by the French. In the background between the hillside and the shakos is a crowd with torches: perhaps onlookers, perhaps more soldiers or victims.

The Second and Third of May 1808 are thought to have been intended as parts of a larger series.[27] Written commentary and circumstantial evidence suggest that Goya painted four large canvases memorializing the rebellion of May 1808. In his memoirs of the Royal Academy in 1867, José Caveda wrote of four paintings by Goya of the second of May, and Cristóbal Ferriz—an artist and a collector of Goya—mentioned two other paintings on the theme: a revolt at the royal palace and a defense of artillery barracks.[27] Contemporary prints stand as precedents for such a series. The disappearance of two paintings may indicate official displeasure with the depiction of popular insurrection

8 comments:

Jen said...

This painting has always disturbed me. I think it's the look in his eyes (white shirt).

Thersites said...

At first I had thought that the Fleet Foxes song was referencing the event depicted by Goya... but I am now convinced that they are wholly unrelated.

Thersites said...

...and yes, this was one of the first instances of modern "political" art so I suspect that it's "intention" was to disturb.

Jen said...

The Fleet Foxes are one of my favorites. I saw them in 2009 and it was beautiful. Have you heard of Father John Misty? He was their drummer and they are noticeably less trippy without him. He's a character.

I read the history of Goya's painting, and I see now why Manet strikes a similar chord.

Thersites said...

No, I'm not familiar with him. I'll have to look on YouTube. ;)

Thersites said...

LOL! What a trip!

Jen said...

Oh, he's something else. People either love him or hate him. I think he goes back and forth between comedy and tragedy, and he gets stuck in that overly self-aware self consciousness that makes him self-righteous and self-loathing at the same time.

Thersites said...

Yes, he's very modern and opinionated, a man of our "age". Definitely NOT a Thucydides, a man who could "objectively" record the misadventures of his day.